Door County stands out not just for its scenic shorelines and outdoor charm but also for its welcoming places to stay. Tucked into small towns and along peaceful roads, historic inns and bed-and-breakfasts offer more than beds they carry the stories of families, old buildings, and the heart of the community.
Many of these inns date back over a hundred years. Each one blends historic beauty with modern comfort. Whether you want Victorian elegance, country peace, or small-town character, Door County has a place that fits.
Historic Inns and B&Bs in Door County
| Property Name | Town | Historic Era | Unique Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| White Gull Inn | Fish Creek | Opened in 1896 | Known for fish boils and lake views |
| Thorp House Inn & Cottages | Fish Creek | Built in 1875 | Listed on the National Register |
| White Lace Inn | Sturgeon Bay | Early 1900s | Victorian homes with antique charm |
| Chanticleer Guest House | Near Sturgeon Bay | Farmhouse conversion | Restored barn and romantic setting |
| Schoolhouse Inn | Baileys Harbor | Over 100 years old | Operates inside a vintage schoolhouse |
White Gull Inn – Tradition in the Heart of Fish Creek
Since 1896, the White Gull Inn has welcomed travelers with a warm setting and old-world touches. The building keeps its early charm, including wooden floors and antique furniture. Guests enjoy rooms with whirlpool tubs and fireplaces.
Its breakfast dishes, including a well-known stuffed French toast, make mornings feel special. The inn also hosts traditional Door County fish boils in the warmer months, creating a unique local experience for guests.
Hidden Gems in Door County You Shouldn’t Miss This Season
Thorp House Inn & Cottages – Rich History and Quiet Comfort
This property began as a private home in 1875. Now, it welcomes guests into its beautifully restored rooms and nearby private cottages. The Thorp House is officially listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
The setting includes gardens and shady trees. Guests can choose to stay in the main inn or pick a cottage for more privacy. This spot blends peaceful surroundings with deep local roots.
White Lace Inn Classic Victorian Style
In downtown Sturgeon Bay, this inn offers 18 rooms spread across four restored Victorian homes. Each room includes elegant period décor, old fireplaces, and claw-foot tubs.
With cozy porches, private gardens, and inviting interiors, the White Lace Inn creates a romantic setting. It’s a popular choice for couples, wedding guests, and those who want to slow down and enjoy the atmosphere of an earlier time.
Top Door County Beaches for Sun, Sand, and Summer Fun
Chanticleer Guest House – Country Setting with Farmhouse Charm
A short drive from Sturgeon Bay, this guest house sits among cherry orchards and woods. The main house and restored barn offer suites decorated with antiques and warm colors. Some rooms include private decks or whirlpool tubs.
It gives guests a quiet, peaceful stay close to hiking trails and nature. This countryside inn blends rustic touches with modern comforts, offering a quiet escape from busy streets.
Baileys Harbor Schoolhouse Inn – History in Every Room
This unique inn turns a former schoolhouse into a one-of-a-kind lodging experience. Built more than a century ago, the structure still carries signs of its past—from original beams to chalkboard walls in some rooms.
Each suite is designed with a different theme, such as a lighthouse or library. Located near Lake Michigan, it offers both comfort and a strong connection to the town’s roots.
Explore Door County Hiking Trails for Beginners to Experienced Hikers
Why Stay at a Historic Inn or B&B?
Historic inns give more than a bed—they offer a story. Each has lived through decades of change, while still keeping pieces of the past alive. Here’s why many travelers prefer these stays:
- Character: These places have charm that newer buildings don’t match.
- History: Guests learn something new, even just by reading the room notes or asking the innkeeper.
- Personal service: Most owners are locals who care deeply about their home and their guests.
- Location: Historic inns are often right in the heart of towns or near beautiful nature spots.
- Memory-making: Staying somewhere special helps create long-lasting travel memories.
Tips for Booking a Historic Stay
- Plan early. Many inns have limited rooms and fill quickly during peak season.
- Choose your style. Some properties feel more romantic, while others are cozy or rustic.
- Ask about amenities. Historic does not mean outdated. Many include modern touches like Wi-Fi, spa tubs, or updated bathrooms.
- Look into packages. Some inns offer discounts or packages with meals and tours.
- Check seasons. Some B&Bs close during winter or offer special off-season rates.
FAQs
Many stay open through all seasons, though some close in winter. It’s best to check in advance.
Yes. Most offer homemade breakfasts as part of the stay.
Yes. While the buildings keep their old look, rooms often include modern comforts like private baths, Wi-Fi, and climate control.
Prices vary. Some are premium, but many offer reasonable rates, especially in spring or fall.
Yes. Properties like Thorp House Inn offer private cottages for more space and privacy.
Historic inns and bed-and-breakfasts bring out the heart of Door County. They offer quiet nights, friendly faces, and rooms full of character. Whether you’re watching the sunset from a wraparound porch or reading in a room that once housed a school desk, these places help travelers connect with the area’s past.
Each stay becomes more than just a trip it becomes a piece of a larger story. A stay in a Door County inn is a chance to rest, explore, and remember.
Goats on the Roof: Door County’s Strangest and Most Loved Landmark